When I meet people and they ask what I do, the obvious answer is, “I’m a designer.” Many people respond, “Oh, an interior designer?” I counter, “No, a graphic designer.” Those familiar with the profession (and yes, there are some that simply do not know it exists) often supply the most exasperating response: “So…you design posters and invitations and make things pretty, right?” And while yes, that is what designers do, when put that way, it sounds irritatingly trivial.
So what is a designer? Simply put, we are visual storytellers and problem solvers. But what does that mean? What role do we play – whether in-house, or agency – in business and within the larger setting of our complex world?
Last week I met up with more than 1,500 of my peers in Phoenix at the bi-annual AIGA design conference to discuss our ever-changing industry. The theme of the conference was ‘pivot’ – a fitting motif referring to the evolving definition and role of designers within the context of major changes to our economy and society.
At the end of the conference, host Kurt Anderson made an astute observation. He recognized that the past three days of stimulating speakers, pragmatic seminars and comprehensive conversations revealed there are two parties of designers – orthodox and reform. Essentially, Party One, the orthodox group, consists of those who feel we live in an flawed world, full of bad design, and that designers need to continue focusing on craft, to develop their technical skills and create better design that results in more beauty in the world. Party Two, the reformers, also believe that we live in imperfection, but that designers need to take on a different role that relies less on craft, and more on our strategic problem-solving skills, to better our world.
Speaker Terry Irwin effectively visualized Party One designers as being in a perpetual hunched-over position, looking down, too focused on the details, unaware of the holistic view. Party Two believes the conventional process of design consultancy is eventually going to die out. Speakers Valerie Casey and Karl Heiselman think designers need to take on a completely new role.
As speaker Chip Kidd said, “if it ain’t good type, it ain’t good design.” We should always remember that no detail is too small, those elements that we obsess over are still important. But we must take on a new strategic role, placing ourselves at the center of business, in a marriage of creativity and rigor, to show the possibilities of business and effect change. It’s our ability to create ideas that will allow us to find new opportunities, and with our design language we can illustrate the possibilities that were never even considered. It’s that meta-disciplinary study and practice that will increase designers value and impact.
This is a critical challenge extended to designers to step up and move from the creative edge to the center. We need to show, as Casey puts it, ”we aren’t just cake decorators; we can bake the cake, too.”
But it’s also a challenge extended to business leaders: stop presenting us as the one-trick pony, the token designer who swoops in and makes things look better. We have the skills to sit at the adult table.
For designers, this is not a shift away from our core principles; it’s a shift toward a new way of thinking about our roles and the increased value we can bring to business and the world. It’s a new perspective on the changing design industry and actionable insights on how to increase our value and improve our practice long term.
There’s a fundamental problem with adhering solely to the beliefs of just Party One or just Party Two and placing oneself into one camp or the other.
The union of these two mindsets is what will ultimately further design. We can’t be exclusively committed to craft and designing pretty things. But we also can’t completely abandon those qualities that make us so unique. Anyone can buy the Adobe Creative Suite and call him or herself a designer, but it’s our skills that will set us apart. It’s not a matter of saying we’ll simply do it better. The key is that we’re going to do it different.
- Carol Scheffler










